Philadelphia Eagles

McMullen | Does NFL have a Pete Morelli problem?

NFL referee Pete Morelli (135) takes the field prior to an NFL football game between the Buffalo Bills and the Pittsburgh Steelers, Sunday, Dec. 11, 2016, in Orchard Park, N.Y. (AP Photo/Adrian Kraus)
Adrian Kraus/AP photo

PHILADELPHIA — The Philadelphia Eagles overcame a number of the typical hurdles any team in the NFL must overcome if it plans on winning on the road during a 28-23 win over the Carolina Panthers on Thursday night.

Injuries, Cam Newton and the Panthers’ tough front seven were expected, however. What wasn’t was the glaring disparity in penalties, one which saw Philadelphia flagged 10 times for 126 yards against Carolina’s one miscue, which cost them a yard and perhaps, more importantly, two points.

Afterward, a number of Eagles coaches and officials took notice of the chasm in between the two numbers and weren’t happy — but it’s not a good idea to publicly criticize officials in this league because the only thing it’s going to accomplish is a fine.

“Ten to one,” Eagles coach Doug Pederson said in an almost unbelieving fashion after the game. “Hey, it’s part of the game. We’ve got to do a better job.”

Perhaps the sting of a loss would have changed things, but Pederson took the high road at his Monday news conference while addressing the discrepancy further, simply stating that all teams send questionable calls to the league office for clarification.

He was also sure to say that many of the calls that went against the Eagles were legitimate ones.

From the league’s perspective, however, it might want to take a look at what is going one with veteran referee Pete Morelli and his crew.

Thursday was the first time in NFL history that one team was penalized for 120 yards or more while the other had fewer than 10 yards.

“We felt like a lot of those were ticky-tack, or weren’t good calls,” Philadelphia safety Malcolm Jenkins said. “Adversity is nothing new for us. We just kind of strap up and keep playing, and hunker down.”

ProFootballTalk.com got a league source to talk about the disparity, however.

“There are penalties on nearly every play, and it’s just whether they are called or not,” the source was quoted as saying. “It’s can’t be this much out of balance — it’s impossible.”

It is impossible but not that big of a deal if it’s just an anomaly. It’s not, however. The last four times Pete Morelli’s crew has been assigned an Eagles game, they’ve all been on the road, and Philadelphia has accumulated 40 flags for 396 yards over that span. The opponents have been whistled eight times for 74 yards.

Last year in Detroit, the numbers were 14 penalties and 111 yards for Philadelphia while the Lions were caught just twice for 18 yards.

This is not just about the Eagles, however.

An NFL source in Minnesota told FanRag Sports that the Vikings were incensed at how Morelli and his crew officiated the Vikings’ Week 2 game in Pittsburgh, in which significant penalties extended Steelers’ offensive drives in an almost consistent fashion.

Meanwhile, the last time Morelli had a game in Philadelphia, ironically when the Eagles hosted the Panthers in 2012, it was Carolina that was flagged for 101 yards.

The commonality here is obviously home versus road, and for whatever reason, the NFL has assembled a crew that is too often letting the environment affect the way it calls a game.

-John McMullen is a national football columnist for FanRagSports.com. You can reach him at jmcmullen44@gmail.com or on Twitter @JFMcMullen




  1. tony

    Oct 13, 2017 at 7:56 pm

    I’m an Eagles fan. Pete Morelli and his gang of goons have consistently made bad and untimely calls one-sided against the Eagles.

    The two games that stand out are last night’s game against Carolina and last year’s game against Detroit. Both games are an example of unbelievably absurd officiating. The Lion’s game Morelli called a fumble recovery by Detroit when the players was half in bounds and half out of bounds and lying on top of the ball.

    It changed the whole game and it was the reason Philly lost and broke a 4 game winning streak.

    Morelli tried hard to keep Carolina in the game last night. The two biggest plays for Carolina came by Morelli’s flags.

    • crosseyedlemon

      Oct 14, 2017 at 8:02 am

      It appears that even Ed Hochuli (the dean of referees with 292 games logged) isn’t a great fan of the Eagles. During a December 2015 game in Buffalo he made 15 of his 20 calls against Philly.

  2. crosseyedlemon

    Oct 13, 2017 at 7:49 pm

    I made a comment last week about a need for consistent officiating when 11 of 12 penalties called in the Detroit game went against the Panthers. Thursday saw 10 of 11 penalties go in the Panthers favor, so although this may all be just a strange coincidence, cynics like myself have to wonder if some attempt to manipulate game outcomes by officials isn’t occurring on some occasions.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

To Top